August 1, 2024
Gr 5-8-Kyle and Clay have always taken part in the stage crew in their drama class, but for the final production of their middle school career, both are considering taking an onstage role. Only Clay follows through, and Kyle stays in his comfort zone in a backstage role. The best friends have lots of ups and downs, and Clay considers quitting. During all the comings and goings, Kyle and Clay start a podcast and it becomes an instant hit, catapulting them into notoriety. The story lags at times and it takes a while for the "problem" to rev up, but readers will likely keep reading because of Kyle and Clay's humorous personalities as well as a lively cast of supporting characters. Readers will be encouraged to embrace their individuality and creative expression. A vibrant color palette brings the story to life and the illustrations set the kooky tone of the story as much as the plot. VERDICT This is another fine addition to the middle grade graphic novel genre that embraces individuality and lets readers know it's okay to be themselves and no one is perfect.-Esther Keller
Copyright 2024 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
Starred review from August 15, 2024
Uncertain stars find their spotlights one step at a time. Clay and Kyle are used to operating behind the scenes in their middle school's drama club. Their creative ambitions snowball from a comedic spring musical audition to performing improv at a local open mic to co-hosting their own podcast. Having the support of their moms and Lettie, the manager of the cafe and local venue above which they live, is a major help. Joking with one another about their neurodivergence is another (Kyle is autistic; Clay has ADHD). During the course of these entertaining antics, Clay crosses paths with musically talented classmate and instant crush, Dania. The anxieties and triumphs of live performance give each of them room to stress as well as shine. Clay's romantic and aspirational self-doubts become great lessons in self-kindness. Clay is as bold and expressive as her blond mohawk, even if she gets distracted sometimes, while Kyle's lavender curtain of hair betrays his calmer but just as creative personality. Combined with Dania's talent for audio production, these eighth graders can take over streaming and bring down any house. Their authentic banter and earnest enthusiasm will turn readers into would-be subscribers to their show. The fluid, animated illustrations emphasize the characters' facial expressions, and the pastel color palette is fresh and engaging. Clay, Kyle, and their moms read white; Dania and Lettie present Black. A messy, funny, neurodivergent ode to finding your voice and owning your differences. (author's note)(Graphic fiction. 9-13)
COPYRIGHT(2024) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
September 15, 2024
Grades 5-8 Clay and Kyle are best friends both working behind the scenes for their school's drama department. The friends are passionate about comedy and often perform improv at the local venue they live above. When Clay tries out for the school's upcoming production of Gals and Dolls and lands a lead role, she can't believe it. Unfortunately, the play's director isn't quite thrilled with her comedic spin on the role. During rehearsals, Clay develops a crush on her costar, Dania, but fumbles on how to express her feelings and ask her to the eighth-grade dance. Meanwhile, Clay and Kyle are spending their free time working on a new podcast based on their improv comedy, and it's quickly taking off. Will Clay work up the courage to ask Dania to the dance? What does the future hold for Clay and Kyle's podcast, and how does the school play turn out? Readers will absolutely vibe with this warmhearted graphic novel rendered in amiable, expressive artwork about middle-school romance, finding yourself, and following your passion. Sure to appeal to fans of Raina Telgemeier, Svetlana Chmakova, and Jerry Craft.
COPYRIGHT(2024) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.